↓ Ir para o conteúdo principal

← todas as notas

📎 Webclip

The forgotten formula for lovable cities

Sitte argues that cities feel lovable when streets and squares are enclosed, human-scaled, and shaped to frame buildings and monuments. He treats the surrounding urban fabric as part of the experience, not as clutter.

Reading notes
#

  • Old city streets are loved not only for historic buildings but also for the character of the spaces between them.
  • Sitte’s 1889 book argues that successful public spaces are small, enclosed, and intimate.
  • Enclosed squares and streets feel calmer and more protected, like outdoor rooms.
  • Squares work better when entrances are less visually intrusive, especially when streets enter at corners or are bridged over.
  • Large plazas weaken enclosure and make nearby buildings look diminished.
  • Curves and T-junctions can help streets feel visually closed rather than endless.
  • Sitte rejects symmetry as a necessary condition of good urban space.
  • Irregular shapes can still feel harmonious at pedestrian level and can create useful recesses.
  • Monuments work better at the edges of squares than in the middle or on central axes.
  • A plain wall or restrained backdrop can make sculpture look larger and clearer.
  • Buildings also need context: freestanding monuments often look smaller and lonelier than when surrounded by ordinary fabric.
  • The demolition of surrounding buildings around monuments can worsen the effect by removing the frame that gives them scale.
  • Sitte’s approach favors dense, interconnected fabric and small framed squares over exposed plazas.
  • His ideas were influential in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, then largely displaced by modernism.
  • The article presents modernist planning as more anti-Sittesque, with space treated as leftover after buildings are placed.
  • Contemporary urban design is again moving toward Sitte-like principles, including in New Urbanist projects and some mainstream practice.