↓ Ir para o conteúdo principal

← todas as notas

📎 Webclip

Silicon Valley arrogance: “I can tell you which startups will succeed, without even knowing what they do”

The author reacts angrily to Marissa Mayer’s claim that she can predict which startups will succeed just by seeing who is in a co‑working space on Saturdays, and that weekend presence is a major success signal. He links this view to her earlier decision at Yahoo! to ban remote work and her belief that people must be physically together in offices to do their best work. While he accepts that Mayer chose extreme hours for herself at Google, he rejects the idea that long weeks, all‑nighters, and weekend work are prerequisites for others’ success and calls this message both false and already too common in tech. He contrasts Mayer’s criteria with his own definition of success, centered on remote work, reasonable hours, time with family, rest, and low stress, and says that in her framework he would count as a failure, which he embraces happily.

Reading notes
#

  • The post centers on a quote from Marissa Mayer claiming she can tell which startups will succeed by who is in a co‑working office on a Saturday, without knowing what they do.
  • The author lists Mayer’s implied points: weekend work as a leading indicator of success, physical weekend presence as a predictor, and success prediction without knowing a company’s business.
  • He describes these claims as arrogant and silly, questioning whether she could have been serious.
  • He connects this stance to Mayer’s tenure at Yahoo!, where she banned remote work and insisted that people must be in the office together to do great work.
  • The leaked Yahoo! memo is quoted to show an emphasis on physical presence, hallway and cafeteria conversations, and a claim that speed and quality suffer when people work from home.
  • The author notes that Mayer’s view ignores that many companies have succeeded with remote teams.
  • He argues that this mindset explains why Mayer might think office presence on a Saturday lets her identify future winners.
  • In his reading, Mayer’s framework implies that those not physically present in the office have already failed.
  • The article also cites Mayer’s description of her time at Google, where she talks about 130‑hour weeks, frequent all‑nighters, and rare vacations.
  • The author says he does not object to Mayer choosing that schedule for herself and frames it as her personal decision.
  • He draws a line at implying that such extreme work patterns are a key to success for other people.
  • He criticizes the message that success and hard work are only achievable through very long hours and weekend work, calling it false.
  • He notes that this belief about extreme hours is already widespread in the tech industry.
  • The author acknowledges Mayer’s conventional business success in terms of money, title, and status.
  • He contrasts his own life: no weekend work, no 130‑hour weeks, and no office commute.
  • His personal success metrics include time with his kids, reading, watching movies, eating treats, occasional travel, and getting eight hours of sleep.
  • He describes himself as rarely stressed and comfortable being “boring and old” while still enjoying his job and coworkers.
  • He points out that he and his colleagues mostly work remotely and seldom see each other in person.
  • By Mayer’s standards, he concludes that he would not count as a success.
  • He ends by saying he is extremely happy to be considered a failure under that definition and notes that Basecamp 3 and its Android app were built fully remotely.
  • The post closes with a request for readers to like it and a brief mention of his weekday work on Basecamp 3.