Read Less. Learn More.
The article argues that in a world flooded with TV, books, websites, and social media, trying to consume more and faster leaves people exhausted and less able to learn. The author describes a personal year of extreme consumption using audiobooks at high speed and speed‑reading apps, which led to shallow recall and almost no real understanding. Drawing on research about willpower, decision fatigue, and differences between screen and paper reading, the piece distinguishes short‑term remembering from deeper knowing, and claims that fast, distracted reading treats books as disposable data. Slow, focused reading, by contrast, supports deeper comprehension, integration of ideas, and original thought. The author suggests practical habit changes: turning off notifications, dropping book‑count goals, rereading, taking notes, and treating reading as a way to grow rather than a metric to optimize.
Reading notes#
- The author opens by challenging the assumption that more books read equals more learning, suggesting that one deeply read book can be more valuable than many skimmed ones.
- Modern life is depicted as saturated with information, from thousands of TV shows and hundreds of thousands of books to billions of websites and tweets each year.
- Randall Munroe’s punch‑card analogy for Google’s data is used to illustrate the almost unimaginable scale of digital information.
- The text argues that keeping up with this information ocean is impossible, yet people still attempt it by constantly scanning and skimming content on phones.
- Examples of tech products (Audible speed controls, Overcast Smart Speed, Twitter, Snapchat, Rooster, Serial Reader, Blinkist, Summize, Spritz) show an ecosystem built around faster, more compressed consumption.
- Citing work on information overload, the article notes that even in 1997 managers were frequently disrupted by email, and interruptions have only intensified with smartphones and modern communication tools.
- A linked Wall Street Journal piece is referenced to claim that office workers are now interrupted or self‑interrupted roughly every three minutes.
- The author connects constant information exposure to decision fatigue, explaining that executive function is limited and exhausts with overuse.
- When executive function is depleted, people make poorer decisions and can even become unable to choose at all, a state related to analysis paralysis.
- Everyday examples (being too tired to decide what to eat, swatting away notifications) illustrate how overload drains motivation and resistance to unhealthy choices.
- The author maintains support for literacy and reading but argues that simply increasing consumption speed will not clear the “data smog” or improve learning.
- In a personal experiment during 2015, the author set goals to watch 300 movies and read 80 books on top of regular digital intake.
- The goals were exceeded: 89 books and 355 movies in a year, which the author frames as an absurd level of input.
- To meet the reading target, the author relied on tactics like audiobooks, playing them at 2x and 3x speed, multitasking while listening, and using Spritz.
- Reflecting on the year, the author feels that very little was truly learned despite the high volume of books consumed.
- The author discovered that comprehension dropped as speed increased, with 2x audio being the upper limit for short bursts and 3x leaving large gaps in understanding even with full attention.
- Attempts to multitask (checking email or browsing while listening) failed because the brain could not process two streams of verbal information at once.
- The described response to overload was mental shutdown or blocking one input, which defeated the purpose of multitasking.
- Spritz is singled out as producing the worst comprehension, even at its slowest settings.
- While using Spritz on Kingsley Amis’s “Old Devils,” the author reports remembering almost nothing of the portions read that way, only a blur of flashing words.
- The text compares this experience to reading one word out of every two lines and argues that such sparse capture of data cannot support real learning.
- Spritz is characterized as more like a form of mental torture than a genuine reading aid in this context.
- Many of the books from that year remain only as vague memories of context (location, weather) and general plot, not as detailed or meaningful experiences.
- The author can often recount what a book was about and a few scenes but cannot articulate its deeper meaning or best parts.
- This superficial familiarity is likened to describing a city that one has only driven through without stopping.
- The article then introduces a distinction between “remembering” and “knowing” as two main forms of storing information.
- Remembering is defined as basic recall that relies heavily on context, is slower to retrieve, and fades quickly.
- School examples (algebra, chemistry, memorizing the periodic table and quadratic equations to pass tests but forgetting later) illustrate remembering.
- Knowing is described as digesting information as truth that becomes part of oneself and can be explained to others.
- Essays, science projects, and study groups are presented as educational tools designed to promote knowing rather than rote memory.
- Parenting provides another example: children may remember warnings about a hot stove in vivid contextual detail yet still touch it.
- The text claims that children only truly know the danger after burning themselves, distinguishing experiential knowledge from mere recall.
- A 2003 University of Leicester study by Kate Garland is cited to compare reading study material on screens versus on paper.
- Participants read introductory economics content either on a computer monitor or in a spiral‑bound notebook and then took comprehension tests.
- Both groups scored equally on comprehension, but their recall patterns differed substantially.
- Students who read on screen mainly relied on remembering, searching their minds for triggered memories.
- Students who read on paper were reported to learn more thoroughly and quickly and often simply knew the answers without laborious mental searching.
- The author notes that this could be interpreted as evidence that paper is inherently superior for learning but offers another possibility.
- It is suggested that perception may drive the difference: people might treat paper as more permanent and online material as disposable.
- This perceived permanence could influence how the brain processes and stores information from each medium.
- The article proposes that data, information, and facts are associated with remembering, while knowledge is linked to knowing.
- Knowledge is portrayed as integrated into personal identity, becoming part of who a person is.
- The text contrasts the role of archives, which store articles for future retrieval, with books, which are framed as tools for personal growth.
- Books are said to be intended as additions to one’s sense of self rather than mere containers of data.
- The author argues that speed‑focused reading goals cause people to treat books as consumables and to focus on remembering instead of knowing.
- When books are viewed mainly as items to ingest quickly, their content becomes temporary rather than deeply integrated.
- The discussion then turns to “deep reading” and its link to deeper thinking.
- The Slow Book Movement, founded in 2009 by I. Alexander Olchowski, is introduced as advocating for deep reading.
- John Miedema’s idea is quoted: to internalize a book and mix an author’s ideas with one’s own, one must read slowly.
- The article claims this reasoning is intuitive and does not require heavy scientific backing for most readers.
- Focus is described as essential for both remembering and knowing, as shown by the author’s failed attempts to absorb audiobooks while handling email.
- Shallow reading is presented as an unintended result of fear of missing out and consumerism rather than a deliberate choice.
- The author links the drive to consume more content to a market logic where greater consumption increases opportunities to sell.
- Spritz’s marketing claim that eliminating eye movements saves time is acknowledged as sounding plausible on the surface.
- However, psychologists and reading experts interviewed by The New Yorker are cited as skeptical of such speed‑reading promises.
- Michael Masson is quoted as saying that regressive eye movements help repair comprehension failures.
- Masson’s studies are described as showing that eye movements on a page are essential to comprehension.
- Without the ability to look back, the brain rushes forward, leaving significant gaps in understanding while trying to assemble meaning from limited input.
- This undermines not only the current passage but also later sections that depend on properly understanding what came before.
- The article uses detective and mystery metaphors to illustrate that missing earlier clues makes later resolution impossible.
- The author connects this explanation directly to their own Spritz experience with “Old Devils,” resulting in disjointed fragments instead of a coherent narrative.
- Slow reading is portrayed as a way to ensure comprehension of the current text and to invite related thoughts.
- The piece acknowledges that initial intruding thoughts may be trivial but suggests that, with practice, they become more relevant and connected.
- Over time, slower reading enables the recognition of similarities and differences with other things one has read.
- These mental connections are described as the core of learning, which is framed as digestion rather than simple data collection.
- Learning is presented as the process that moves information from remembering to knowing.
- This process is characterized as the deepest form of thinking described in the article.
- The author notes that a single isolated idea is insufficient to generate thought; ideas need other ideas to interact with.
- The Hegelian Dialectical Formula is invoked: a thesis meets an antithesis to produce a synthesis, representing new thought.
- By reading in a relaxed, unhurried way, readers can build focus, reduce anxiety, support learning, and create space for original ideas.
- The final section addresses how to start reading less while learning more.
- The author calls for unlearning unhealthy information‑age habits rather than abandoning technology outright.
- Readers are reassured that they need not discard computers, smash phones, quit social media, or stop reading online articles.
- The key is described as turning vague habits into deliberate practices.
- Practical steps include setting personal limits, turning off notifications, and focusing on what is in front of you.
- Allowing time to reflect instead of repeatedly checking a phone is recommended as a way to change reading behavior.
- The author advises resisting pressure to rush through books or to compete with others on the number of books finished.
- Keeping a notebook nearby while reading and writing down thoughts is suggested as a way to deepen engagement.
- Rereading difficult sentences and reasoning through them is encouraged to reach genuine understanding.
- Readers are urged to recover a view of reading as a path to growth rather than a statistic to collect.
- The article concludes by emphasizing that the device or content type matters less than dedicating full attention when reading.
- Readers are encouraged to worry less about what they might be missing and to allow themselves to get absorbed in thought.
- The focus should shift from how much is being read to how much is being learned.
- A quote from Henry David Thoreau is used to close: books should be read as deliberately and reservedly as they were written.
