↓ Ir para o conteúdo principal

← todas as notas

📎 Webclip

On Programmers and Labor Markets

The author needs to learn machine learning and refresh Python for an upcoming workstream but is unenthusiastic about spending personal time on topics that are not intrinsically interesting. They feel unable to refuse learning in their free time because many programmers willingly devote large amounts of unpaid overtime to self-training, which sets employer expectations, especially given already high compensation.

They reject the idea that one should only do work that is always interesting, emphasizing being paid to provide value and support the organization’s mission, even when specific tasks are not exciting. Comparing programmers to factory workers, the author argues that if most factory workers voluntarily trained off-hours, those workers would become more valuable and reset the market, which is what has happened in software. Competitive drives for status, money, and activities like competitive programming have helped create a demanding market despite the shortage of engineers. The author believes it is probably too late to reverse this expectation without collective action such as unionization or regulation, doubts that developers will stop chasing “cool” companies with heavy perks, and concludes by considering taking machine learning courses on Coursera and asking for recommendations.

Reading notes
#

  • The author expects to start a new workstream involving machine learning in a few months and will need to re-learn Python after several years away from it.
  • They are not eager to spend dozens of hours of free time learning something they are not very interested in.
  • They would rather use their free time for family, learning more Elixir, or practicing German, which matters for living in Berlin.
  • They feel unable to tell their employer they will not learn required skills on their own time.
  • They observe that many programmers offer large amounts of free overtime for self-training, which helps set market expectations.
  • The author notes that they are already paid very well and wonders if some implicit paid overtime is built into their salary.
  • They address the argument that one should avoid doing work they are not interested in and say they do not accept it.
  • The author sees their job as providing value, not having fun all the time.
  • Even though they are not excited about this new workstream, they strongly believe in the organization’s mission and want to contribute effectively.
  • They also address the comparison to factory workers who do not usually go home and learn new factory tools.
  • The author imagines a scenario where factory workers do spend free time improving job-related skills and become more valuable because employers save on training costs.
  • In that scenario, those workers would get better and higher paying jobs, shifting the market.
  • If most factory workers did extra factory-related work for fun at home, that behavior would define the market standard for the skill.
  • The author argues that software engineers have done something similar, creating a market where self-training in personal time is expected.
  • They highlight that there are far more programming jobs than engineers, yet the labor market remains demanding for workers.
  • According to the author, developers’ competitiveness for glory, money, or other motivations, including activities like competitive programming, fuels this demanding environment.
  • They contend that this expectation of off-hours work is a “monster” created by programmers themselves.
  • The author thinks it is likely too late to roll back these expectations, especially given the influx of new engineers from code schools.
  • They argue that only some form of collective action, such as unionization or regulation, could prevent off-hours competition from setting standards.
  • Another possible change would be programmers caring less about working for “cool” companies with extravagant perks, though the author doubts this will occur.
  • They note that companies intentionally invest in turning offices into environments resembling frat houses for young engineers because this approach is effective.
  • The piece ends with the author considering taking machine learning courses on Coursera and asking for recommendations.