How Much Do They Suffer?
The text revisits the “monkey” metaphor of delegation and argues that the usual advice about keeping responsibility on subordinates’ shoulders fails in practice. Through an example of a startup co‑founder helping her marketing team upload videos, the author shows how employees can successfully push responsibility back to managers when they themselves have little to lose. The core claim is that leaders often delegate work but not the consequences, which leaves them worrying more than their staff and absorbing the real risks.
The author defines “worry” as a combination of rewards and punishments tied to outcomes. In the story, the co‑founder has strong personal stakes in the expo’s success, while the two marketers receive mostly fixed salaries and only small bonuses, so they care less about the result. The piece argues that professional employees deliberately try to move monkeys back up the hierarchy and that managers must ensure subordinates suffer or benefit proportionally from project outcomes; otherwise responsibility slides upward and the team structure is hollow.
Reading notes#
- The article references “Who’s Got the Monkey?” and its idea that good managers keep responsibility with subordinates instead of accepting excuses.
- The author claims this principle usually fails because most managers still end up carrying the responsibility their subordinates try to return.
- A dinner anecdote introduces a startup co‑founder who leaves the table to urgently help her marketing team upload videos needed for an expo.
- Her team is at an expo abroad and depends on her exclusive access to the company’s YouTube channel to get videos ready for a conference the next morning.
- She feels that if she does not help, their expo mission will fail, which she reads as her own failure as a co‑founder.
- Reframed in “monkey” terms, she initially delegated the expo work, but the team sent the monkey back by asking for help, and she kept it on her shoulders.
- The expo outcome would then depend on her remembering the task, giving the team a ready excuse if things went wrong.
- The author notes that experienced employees usually try hard to send monkeys back to bosses, while only junior or incompetent workers simply follow orders without defending themselves.
- Seasoned experts are described as knowing how to manage their managers by pushing responsibility upward.
- In this situation, the author argues the co‑founder’s mistake was failing to make her employees worry enough about the expo results.
- She had clearly communicated that the expo outcome was important and hired them with the expectation of bringing back leads or similar results.
- Despite this, the marketers worried less than she did, shown by their lack of constant follow‑up calls and poor planning of the video uploads.
- “Worry” is defined as the combined effect of rewards and punishments that follow success or failure, regardless of the terminology used.
- The co‑founder knew the personal rewards of a successful expo and the personal risks of failure but did not transfer these stakes proportionally to her team.
- According to her description, the marketers received a monthly salary and some per‑lead bonuses, with bonuses much smaller than salary.
- The author questions how employees can be expected to care deeply about leads when the pay structure signals that steady salary matters more than performance.
- The text states that leaders typically break down big objectives into smaller ones and delegate them, but they often omit delegating the related consequences.
- An objective is described as including the consequences subordinates face when they either succeed or fail at it.
- Monthly salary is criticized as a poor tool for delegating consequences because it implies employees are fine until the extreme step of being fired, with no meaningful gradations.
- In the expo case, the marketers probably would not be fired over missing videos, and they can justify themselves by saying they asked for help that was not delivered.
- The author summarizes that good managers arrange things so that the suffering subordinates feel from mistakes exceeds the damage those mistakes cause to the project, and similarly align rewards.
- At the same time, the text acknowledges that it is unrealistic to assign all blame for business failure or all credit for success to a single individual.
- The proposed goal is to make every team member gain and lose in proportion to their part in the outcome.
- The author concludes that without this proportional sharing of consequences, a group cannot function as a real team.
- A closing question on social media asks what a reader’s boss will do if they miss a deadline, inviting reflection on how consequences are currently handled.
