↓ Ir para o conteúdo principal

← todas as notas

📎 Webclip

A Unicorn Lost in the Valley, Evernote Blows Up the ‘Fail Fast’ Gospel

Evernote, founded in 2004 and once a high-flying unicorn, shifted from a simple note-taking app to an overextended lifestyle brand with socks, notebooks, side apps and conferences, before growth slowed and leadership churn, layoffs and office closures set in. The company’s long struggle, now under C.E.O. Ian Small, undercuts Silicon Valley’s “fail fast” mantra, showing how heavily funded start-ups can linger in a drawn-out rehabilitation instead of collapsing quickly.

Evernote chased a “Nike for your mind” vision and three-comma valuations, adding products and perks while amassing more than 150 million registered users and hundreds of millions in venture capital. As hype faded, attempts to pivot into business software ran into product gaps and fragmented apps, leading to weak enterprise sales and employee malaise, even as rumors of a big-tech acquisition failed to materialize. After a wave of executive departures and “death spiral” headlines in 2018, Small publicly acknowledged Evernote’s buggy, unstable foundation and set expectations for a year of fixes, while aiming for positive cash flow around $100 million in annual revenue.

Reading notes
#

  • Evernote at one point tried to extend its brand into physical goods, selling Japanese-made socks, high-end scanners and designer backpacks, and even ran a lobby store called “Noteworthy by Evernote.”
  • The branded retail shelves were later removed, leaving only aging trophies and a painted-over mural that hinted at the abandoned lifestyle vision.
  • Founded in 2004, Evernote rode early smartphone adoption and was widely expected to go public but instead cycled through four C.E.O.s, multiple layoffs, office closures and shut down many side projects.
  • In contrast to recent high-profile I.P.O.s like Slack, Pinterest, Zoom, Uber and Lyft, Evernote ended up in a difficult turnaround under C.E.O. Ian Small, who took over in October before the article.
  • The article contrasts Silicon Valley’s “fail fast, fail often” mantra with the slower, drawn-out decline and rehabilitation that can occur when heavily funded start-ups stall.
  • Once momentum fades, missteps and negative coverage can accumulate, pushing companies into a “start-up purgatory” where they survive for years without dramatic failure.
  • Investors who have committed large sums may tolerate years of floundering, hoping for a big payoff rather than accepting a small loss or modest outcome.
  • The rise of unicorns valued at $1 billion or more encouraged start-ups to pursue massive valuations as a signal that they were too large and special to fail.
  • Many unicorns that pursued lofty valuations have later faced “down rounds” or “down exits,” such as Shazam and the Honest Company.
  • Several well-known unicorns, including Clover Health, Udacity and Instacart, have laid off staff; such moves hurt perceptions of rapid growth and can undermine hiring and fundraising.
  • From Evernote’s Redwood City headquarters, Ian Small can see younger companies like Box that have gone public and now far exceed Evernote in revenue and staff size.
  • Small compares some Silicon Valley companies to rocket ships, while likening Evernote’s trajectory to the Beatles song “The Long and Winding Road.”
  • The article places Evernote among “Remember this?” companies that once commanded hype but then faded from the zeitgeist without disappearing entirely.
  • Zynga is cited as another example of a once-hyped firm whose real estate sale ended up more profitable than its games business after its value collapsed.
  • Other former darlings such as Foursquare and Quora have survived by pivoting or quietly continuing, with Foursquare becoming a location technology provider and Quora planning new fundraising.
  • Evernote’s slogan “Remember Everything” and user enthusiasm helped it reach unicorn status in 2012, with job applicants submitting elaborate videos, including a song about helping the world remember.
  • Then-C.E.O. Phil Libin promoted a vision of Evernote as “the Nike for your mind,” describing it as a “100-year start-up” during its period of exuberant growth.
  • Using large venture funding, Evernote expanded into a chat app, recipe app, contacts manager and flashcard app, and pushed an e-commerce strategy with branded Moleskine notebooks and a Post-it partnership.
  • Growth slowed around 2015, leading to Libin’s replacement by Chris O’Neill, a former Google executive who moved to cut costs and refocus the company.
  • O’Neill reduced staff, shut down side projects, cancelled perks like weekly sushi lunches and house cleaners, closed international offices and raised subscription prices.
  • His strategy was to push Evernote into business software and enterprise markets, but the product lacked key features and its fragmented apps across platforms hampered collaboration.
  • According to people familiar with the company, revenue from Evernote’s business product never surpassed 15 percent of its total revenue.
  • Employees spread rumors of a potential acquisition by Microsoft or Google, while meetings under a cardboard elephant head were colored by a sense that the company was just “fine” rather than likely to succeed.
  • Despite internal difficulties, Evernote maintained a public posture of success, as is common among start-ups, even when four top executives resigned in 2018.
  • A New York Times Styles piece on O’Neill’s workout routine appeared tone-deaf given Evernote’s struggles, and he soon departed.
  • After taking over, Ian Small decided he could not ignore disgruntled users and “death spiral” coverage and opted for an unusually candid communication.
  • In a January blog post, Small told users that Evernote’s foundation was weak and its products had accumulated a distinctive cluster of bugs and unwanted behaviors.
  • He warned that fixing the underlying problems would take most of the year and acknowledged that some users would still be disappointed.
  • Users reacted to his openness with both optimism and skepticism, but Small saw the honesty as a departure from typical tech company communication.
  • Small’s task now is to recruit engineers to repair deeply embedded product issues while competing with newer, faster-growing companies that can offer more lucrative opportunities.
  • Hot start-ups can attract top engineering talent with higher spending because they can raise funds easily when growth is strong.
  • Evernote’s current goal is more modest, aiming for positive cash flow with nearly $100 million in annual revenue rather than pursuing breakneck expansion.
  • Small describes the company as having once been a “movement,” suggesting that its cultural moment did not translate into a sustainable business at the time.
  • The article notes a growing skepticism among founders and executives toward the venture-backed hypergrowth model, including from people who once benefited from it.
  • Technology insiders often blame diffuse entities like the media, investors or “Silicon Valley” for problems linked to hype cycles.
  • Former C.F.O. Vincent Toolan argues that Evernote’s core business would look enviable outside Silicon Valley, but its location skews expectations.
  • Sequoia Capital partner and board member Roelof Botha rejects the view of Evernote as adrift, saying the current negative narrative understates the company’s reality, just as earlier coverage was overly positive.
  • Small pushes back on the boom-and-bust framing, pointing out that Evernote apps are still downloaded about 50,000 times daily despite complaints and internal disruptions.
  • With around half the staff it once had, Evernote can still recruit from dedicated power users who remain attached to the product.
  • Small notes that Evernote may not be trendy, but some users still regard it as cool, and he has even brought back several former employees.
  • He characterizes the company as having outlasted a “snark phase” of criticism and positions it as ready for a potential comeback story, suggesting that industry observers hope “the elephant” will regain momentum.