↓ Ir para o conteúdo principal

← todas as notas

📎 Webclip

Are You Unhired or Unfired?

The article introduces two concepts: being “unfired,” when someone still holds and performs a role that the company no longer truly needs, and being “unhired,” when roles that would once have existed are never created. Using the Unhired Index, it shows that by late 2025 nine large software firms employed about 185,000 fewer people than their historical revenue–headcount relationship would predict, even as business kept growing. The text reviews competing explanations for this divergence, including AI, uncertainty, rate hikes, and the unwinding of 2021 over‑hiring, and argues that shocks such as the pandemic or AI investment spur firms to finally realize productivity gains made possible by earlier waves of technology and organizational change.

It highlights how remote work followed this pattern: the capacity existed for years but only became widespread when COVID forced adoption. AI is framed primarily as a shock that pushes companies to test how much they can do with existing staff, with its own further productivity gains likely to surface during future shocks. Meta is used as an example of a company that grew revenue and margins while reducing headcount, confirming that a much larger operation can run with fewer employees. Leaders like Mark Zuckerberg and Elon Musk embraced leaner organizations early, and Microsoft has now offered voluntary exits to tens of thousands of employees. At the same time, major tech firms pour money into capital expenditure rather than payroll, underscoring that industry success no longer guarantees job security. For people early in their careers, the main threat is being unhired when openings never appear; for those in comfortable corporate roles, it is becoming unfired without realizing it, which makes it crucial to assess whether one’s work would be replaced, redistributed, or simply vanish without affecting the company’s growth.

Reading notes
#

  • Defines “unfired” as continuing in a job that is already unnecessary but not yet eliminated, sometimes for months or years
  • Defines “unhired” as roles that would have existed under previous patterns but are never created under current conditions
  • Notes that by the end of 2025, nine major software firms had about 185,000 fewer employees than predicted by their pre‑2020 revenue–employment relationship, as tracked by the Unhired Index
  • Reports that for a decade revenue and headcount rose together, with a brief over‑hiring phase in 2022 that was corrected by late 2023, followed by a 16% employment shortfall versus the old pattern by the end of 2025
  • Emphasizes that revenue kept growing even as the predicted headcount failed to materialize, evidencing unhired positions
  • Summarizes debates among economists: Goldman Sachs cites AI, others highlight that the divergence is mainly a US tech phenomenon beginning before widespread generative AI deployment
  • Adds that prior commentary tied the hiring pullback to rate hikes and uncertainty, while some observers attribute it to unwinding 2021 over‑hiring
  • Argues that distinguishing between a temporary correction and an ongoing technological shift matters because each has different implications
  • Suggests another explanation: companies may now be realizing productivity improvements that have been technically possible for years
  • Describes how economic shocks reveal accumulated productivity gains that were not fully exploited beforehand
  • Lists prior changes before generative AI: software permeated processes, cloud computing replaced server rooms, and the pandemic forced digitization of previously resistant activities
  • Notes that remote collaboration spread as millions learned to work together from afar and some CEOs recognized that they could operate with fewer middle managers
  • Explains that organizations do not automatically adopt the most efficient practices when revenue is rising; managers often respond to more work by adding headcount because that is the familiar approach
  • States that shocks—negative like pandemics or crises, or positive like powerful new technologies requiring investment—shift management focus from how many people to add to how few to keep
  • Defines this moment of reassessment as when “pent‑up productivity” surfaces, revealing the gap between technological capability and actual organizational practice
  • Uses remote work as an example where the ability to work from anywhere preceded widespread adoption, which only surged when COVID forced companies to use it
  • Quotes a prior prediction that office landlords faced oversupply due to people’s ability and desire to work remotely, showing that the capability existed years before the shift
  • Argues that AI plays a similar role, with hiring restraint starting in 2022 prompting firms to test output levels using existing staff
  • Frames AI’s main near‑term impact on tech jobs as a shock encouraging companies to exploit existing productivity gains, with AI‑generated gains accumulating and likely to be fully visible after future shocks
  • Presents Meta as a case: from a 2022 headcount peak to a 9% workforce reduction by late 2025 while revenue grew 72% and margins also improved
  • Observes that Meta’s performance does not disentangle contributions from technology, management, or market conditions but does show that a much larger business can run with fewer employees
  • Notes that Mark Zuckerberg and Elon Musk were early adopters of the idea that companies can operate with significantly leaner staffing
  • Recalls earlier commentary describing remote work’s first‑order effect as empty offices and second‑order effect as leaner companies
  • Points out that once some firms prove a new operating model works, others start to emulate them
  • Cites Microsoft’s voluntary exit offers to up to 60,000 employees, roughly 27% of its workforce, as an illustration of this shift
  • Highlights that these firms are not reducing labor to retrench; they continue to invest heavily in expansion while cutting or restraining headcount
  • Reports that over the four quarters through Q3 2026, combined capital expenditure by Amazon, Microsoft, Alphabet, Meta, and Oracle equaled the cost of about 10.7 million median US annual salaries
  • Clarifies that this is a scale comparison rather than a figure for jobs lost, and that building and operating data centers still generates employment elsewhere
  • Uses this spending pattern to argue that working in a booming sector or successful firm now offers less assurance of personal job security
  • States that people early in their careers face a greater risk of being unhired, when openings for junior roles never materialize
  • States that workers already in desirable corporate roles should be more concerned about becoming unfired within a large organization
  • Proposes a self‑test: consider whether the employer would fill the position if the person left, redistribute tasks among colleagues, or let the tasks lapse while the company continues to grow
  • Suggests that organizations may take a long time to recognize when a role has become unnecessary, giving employees a window to notice first
  • Encourages individuals who realize they are unfired to either find a role that truly requires them or reshape their current role to become genuinely indispensable, at least temporarily

Related notes#